The Healthiest In-N-Out Burger Orders—and What To Skip

In-N-Out Burger holds a special place in the hearts of Californians and burger enthusiasts across the country. In 1948, In-N-Out pioneered the drive-thru restaurant concept as a modest 10-square-foot hamburger stand with no inside seating. Since then, the fast food chain has garnered a cult-like following for its simplicity and fresh ingredients.

Despite its remarkable growth, In-N-Out's small menu has barely changed in 76 years. This commitment to simplicity is central to the brand's ethos which emphasizes high-quality, fresh ingredients and "handmade" burgers—a dedication that has earned praise from award-winning chefs. Along with its craveable flavors, In-N-Out's popularity is driven by affordable prices, made possible by a streamlined menu, company-owned locations, and wholesale ingredient sourcing.

While everyone knows In-N-Out for its mouthwatering burgers, let's take a closer look at what's going on between the bun from a nutritional perspective.

Is In-N-Out Healthy?

Compared to other popular burger chains like Burger King or McDonald's, In-N-Out can be a healthier fast-food option, but it ultimately depends on how you order.

In-N-Out's commitment to using fresh ingredients—like 100% pure beef and hand-cut fries—gives it an edge in terms of food quality. Because it offers customizations like Protein Style burgers, which replace the bun with lettuce, and simple condiments such as ketchup and mustard, there are plenty of ways you can make your meal at In-N-Out lower in calories and fat than many offerings from other chains.

However, when it comes to sodium and saturated fat, In-N-Out's menu isn't necessarily better across the board. Certain menu items like the Quad-Quad or Animal Style burgers can be just as indulgent as a Big Mac or Whopper.

So, while In-N-Out has healthier options, it's all about how you customize your order to make it a better choice compared to other fast-food burgers.

How To Order Healthy In-N-Out Menu Items

Since the menu is basic, it's quite easy to order better options at the chain. Here are three tips for how to order the healthiest choices when at the chain.

• Opt for Protein Style, where the bun is replaced with lettuce.
• Skip the Animal Style options, which means it has mustard in each patty plus pickles, grilled onion, and extra special sauce. More extra special sauce adds too much low-calorie
• Skip the special spread and ask for just ketchup and mustard to shave calories and fat. The special sauce is estimated to contain 80 calories and 9g fat.
• Avoid the not-so-secret menu. The options on this menu tend to be higher in calories, sat fat, sodium and added sugar.

The Healthiest In-N-Out Orders

• Protein Style Cheeseburger
• Protein Style Hamburger with Ketchup and Mustard (No Spread)
• Hamburger with Ketchup and Mustard (No Spread)
• Double-Double Protein Style with Ketchup and Mustard (No Spread)
• French Fries
• Vanilla Shake

Protein Style Cheeseburger

This core menu item is the regular cheeseburger (1 all-beef patty and 1 slice American Cheese) wrapped in lettuce rather than on a bun. This option makes our best bet due to its modest calories, and better saturated fat and sodium counts compared to other burger choices on the menu.

Protein Style Hamburger with Ketchup and Mustard (No Spread)

This is the best option if you're managing your calories and want to eat a fast-food burger. Even ordering two protein style burgers would be better than many of the other menu items at In-N-Out.

Hamburger with Ketchup and Mustard (No Spread)

This menu item is a great option because it has a modest number of calories, is relatively low in saturated fat and provides 16 grams fiber. The sodium is high but is lower than many other main items on the menu.

Double-Double Protein Style with Ketchup and Mustard (No Spread)

This burger has two patties, two slices of cheese, and lettuce in place of a bun. The sodium is high, but the calories, carbs, and protein are all appropriate amounts.

French Fries

The French fries on In-N-Out's menu are better than those from many other chains. They use 100% sunflower oil, which is a highly unsaturated fat. This helps keep the saturated fat content of their fries lower than the fries at other national chains.

Vanilla Shake

Even though this shake is the "healthiest" milkshake option, it's not a recommended menu item. However, if you are going to order a shake, vanilla is marginally better than either the chocolate or strawberry options. The best bets for beverages on the menu include unsweetened tea, water, or a diet soda.

The Unhealthiest In-N-Out Orders

• 4×4 ('Quad Quad') Animal-Style
• Double-Double with Spread
• 3×3 ('Triple Triple') with Spread
• Cheeseburger with Spread
• Animal Style Fries
• Chocolate Shake
• Strawberry Shake

Worst: 4×4 ('Quad Quad') Animal-Style

(Nutritional information is estimated from online sources.)

Also called the Quad Quad, this not-so-secret menu option is as its name suggests: four all-beef patties, four slices of American cheese, and all the standard condiments on a fresh-baked bun. Think of it as a double Double-Double. While the nutritionals are not readily available from In-N-Out, our best estimates show how horrific this option is for your health. It packs in more than half the calories you need in a day, more than a day's worth of saturated fat, all the sodium you should have in a day, and an excessive amount of protein that can be harmful to your kidneys.

 The #1 Unhealthiest Burger at Every Major Fast-Food Chain

Worst: Double-Double with Spread

This burger is a mainstay on the regular In-N-Out menu and it's one to avoid. It packs in excessive saturated fat and sodium. The saturated fat is the same as you'd get from eating 3 tablespoons of butter and the sodium would be equal to what you'd get from two servings of canned soup!

Worst: 3×3 ('Triple Triple') with Spread

(Nutritional information is estimated from online sources.)

This is an option on the not-so-secret menu that includes three beef patties and three slices of American cheese on a bun with all the standard condiments. This heart-stopping burger has about 1.5 times the saturated fat you need in a day, half most adult's daily calories, and nearly all the sodium you should have in a day.

Worst: Cheeseburger with Spread

This burger is considered the best of the worst. It has moderate calories and saturated fat but sodium is quite high. Tweak this choice by skipping the spread and have ketchup and mustard and you'll shave some calories and sodium. For a bigger transformation, order a protein-style cheeseburger.

 How Many Calories Are In A Cheeseburger?

Worst: Animal Style Fries

This not-so-secret option is a larger order of fries topped with melted cheese, In-N-Out spread and grilled onions. It exceeds the calories, fat, saturated fat, sodium, and carbs that you'd want to have in an entire meal.6254a4d1642c605c54bf1cab17d50f1e

Worst: Chocolate Shake

This is by far one of the worst In-N-Out menu items, based on calories, saturated fat, and added sugar. This shake packs in just over 15 teaspoons of added sugar and nearly a day's worth of artery-clogging saturated fat.

 The 9 Worst Fast-Food Milkshakes of All Time, Says Dietitian

Worst: Strawberry Shake

Like the chocolate shake, the strawberry shake has all the same nutritional flaws: excessive calories, saturated fat, sodium, and added sugar. The vanilla shake is only modestly better than the strawberry or chocolate flavors.