Skip to content

7 Best Member’s Mark Items at Sam’s Club, According to Members

Evidence-Based
From rotisserie chicken to smash burgers, these Member’s Mark favorites are worth adding to your cart.

If there is one thing Sam’s Club members appreciate about the members-only club, it is the store’s in-house Member’s Mark brand. Famous for high-quality for less food, name-brand dupes, and in-store cooked items, some shoppers maintain the brand is worth the membership dues alone. What should you grab on your next Sam’s Club shopping trip? Here are the 7 best Member’s Mark items at Sam’s Club, according to members.

Member’s Mark Rotisserie Chicken

Sam's Club

Sam’s shoppers maintain that the warehouse’s rotisserie chicken is better than Costco. “I think the Costco birds are a hair bigger than Sams but the seasoning alone of Sams Club rotisserie chicken makes up for any shortcomings. I didn’t realize how tasty rotisserie chicken could be,” one says. “I just left sams club and got the rotisserie chicken. They definitely season it, it was so damn good,” says a third.

Member’s Mark Southern Fried Sandwich

Sam's Club

The Member’s Mark Southern Fried Sandwich is another favorite. Each is fully cooked, lightly breaded patty, and individually wrapped with 23 grams of protein per sandwich. “Chick-Faux-Lay! It’s pretty darn close!” one shopper raves. “This sandwich (yes – it even comes with the bun but you have to provide your own pickles!) is amazing. It tastes pretty close to the CFA version. It’s pretty well known that the national chain marinates the chicken in pickle juice & you can definitely taste it in this version as well.”

Members Mark Smash Burgers

Sam's Club

Member’s Mark Smashed Burgers are another hit. Each box comes with 20 pre-smashed, perfectly seasoned Angus beef patties ready for the grill. They deliver juicy, crispy-edged flavor without the prep work, making them a new cookout must-have. “Best burgers ever,” writes a shopper. “I’ve had a lot of store bought burgers but these are the best in my opinion, they’re affordable and remind me of Shake Shack burgers especially if you use potato buns but honestly any bun is good especially pretzel buns! I will continue buying these, never discontinue them Sam’s Club, please!”

Member’s Mark Southern Style Chicken Bites

Sam's Club

Another Chick-fil-A dupe? Member’s Mark Southern Style Chicken Bites are “Just like Chick Fil A,” writes a shopper. “These are so delicious and they taste just like Chick Fil A. This is my go to meal. I just pop them in the air fryer and I’m done. My whole family loves them. They are very big pieces.” Another agrees they are “Chic-fil-a knock-off chicken bites!” in another review. “If you’re looking for an at-home chic-fil-a substitute…this is it! The kids absolutely love these! I think it’s the hint of pickle that sets it apart!”

Member’s Mark Mini Pizza Bagels

Sam's Club

Member’s Mark Mini Pizza Bagels are a cheaper version of Bagel Bites. Shoppers approve. “Excellent! Taste like Bagel Bites!” writes one shopper. “JUST AS GOOD AS THE BRAND,” adds another. “Better than the others,” a third agrees. “Baked in the toaster oven–perfectly crunchy and melty.”

Member’s Mark Cauliflower Cheese Pizza

Sam's Club

Member’s Mark Cauliflower Cheese Pizza is another favorite. “MM frozen cauliflower cheese pizza; I buy multiple boxes a week for easy lunches!” one person said. “Yes! My family loves these even though none of us are gluten free or have any reason to need the cauliflower crust. I use a cheap pizza stone on my gas grill, get it as hot as the grill will go, and put one of these straight from the freezer to the grill for 4-5 minutes and it gives a perfect texture!” another added.

Member’s Mark Double Smoked Bacon

Sam's Club

Member’s Mark Double Smoked Bacon is one of the store’s best-kept secrets. “I just tried it yesterday for the first time, had always bought the Wright bacon. The MM bacon is really good, very meaty,” one shopper wrote. “This is our favorite. I’ve made a trip into Sam’s just for this thick cut bacon. Great to eat or use for meals like bacon wrapped tenderloin or TX poppers,” another says.

Leah Groth
Leah Groth is an experienced shopping editor and journalist for Best Life and Eat This, Not That! bringing readers the best new finds, trends, and deals each week. Read more about Leah